In 2011, JCPenney made what looked like a dream hire.
They brought in Ron Johnson, the retail genius behind Apple’s iconic stores. On paper, it was a masterstroke.
But within months:
- He scrapped the discounts customers loved
- Changed the brand message without understanding the audience
- Replaced staff without a clear transition plan
The result?
- 💸 $4 billion in lost revenue in a single year
- 📉 A 50% drop in share price
- ⏳ Johnson was out in 17 months
Sound familiar?
Well here's another interesting fact:
That 17 months is almost exactly in line with the fact that 40% (!!!) of executives fail within their first 18 months.
And here’s the kicker: This wasn’t just a hiring mistake. It was a leadership mistake.
The Real Reason Execs Fail
Most companies onboard roles, not outcomes.
That means the focus is on contracts, systems, and introductions, but not on:
- What success actually looks like in 6–12 months
- How this leader needs to adapt to the company’s culture
- What support they need to deliver impact fast
The result? Even great people fail to gain traction.
What To Do Instead
Strong executive onboarding is about alignment and support, not just logistics.
Ask yourself:
- Mission: Does this leader know why their role exists right now?
- Outcomes: Have we defined 3–5 clear results they must deliver in the first year?
- Cultural adaptability: Do they know how decisions are really made here? What dynamics they must navigate?
- Support: Do they have coaching, sponsorship, or structured check-ins to accelerate impact?
Final Thought
Executive failure isn’t inevitable. It’s predictable (and preventable).
When you define outcomes up front and support leaders through transition, you protect both the hire and the business.
Want more like this?
I write a weekly email for leaders who want to make the right hiring decisions. No fluff. Just real tools and insight that help you hire smarter.
Sign up using the link below and get my 15-Minute Interview Framework for FREE.
